Friday, May 14, 2010

Cabinet Top Decoration Ideas

Selector Repairs to strict guidelines on ASD and intellectual disability. Clarifications

.
First anniversary of the birth of Miguel Hernández .
Child psychiatry in gray.
.
.
.
TOPICS AND MYTHS ABOUT AUTISM
.
ALL HAVE CHILDREN WITH MENTAL RETARDATION TGD
THREE IN FOUR CHILDREN WITH PDD Mental retardation
.

read in the Guide:
.
" The most widespread misconceptions about the TEA is below. Each idea is accompanied by an explanation of why they are wrong:
.
Topic 2: All children with ASD have mental retardation. Although there are often cognitive impairment, some children with ASD have normal IQ scores and one above average, and others have special skills in areas such as math or calculus, music, painting, etc., but these features do not have the majority. " page. 133; Guide autism) (3).

The Guide have taken up the topic so that when they try to fight it but do not insist on it. There are some children with ASD who have normal IQ scores but the vast majority between 70.2 to 74, 2%, according to the literature you manage.

Topics are misconceptions, but its effects are real. We think, for example, and outdated idea that young children should always be very warm. The mothers act according to that topic and the children were actually lined with an endless succession of clothes but nobody did anything about it until it was several centuries.
.
Guide rectify accepted that 70% of children with ASD have intellectual disabilities (mental retardation) [ correction date: May 7, 2010; explanation of the changes in Section Corrections ] and gave the following reformulation:
.
" In regard to the effect of cognitive ability, according to some authors, intellectual disability among people with autistic disorder is 67% (29% with mild cognitive impairment and 38% with moderate to severe cognitive impairment) 17 "
.
However, this text can be seen that 67% of individuals with intellectual disabilities associated with ASD. Keep in mind that paragraph is under title says Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorders and associated disease burdens, and is therefore very easy to identify autistic disorder with autism spectrum disorder, when two completely different things. The autistic disorder is a subcategory of TGD , while autism spectrum disorder, ASD, encompasses all subcategories . TEA TGD equals , by a convention determined by the authors of the Guide.
.
1. At this point, "why not put clearly the result given the baseline study ( 17 ) ?. "Why not put the percentage of intellectual disabilities associated with ASD, which consists in the study cited Chakrabarti and Fombonne (2005)?.

This percentage is clearly left on the table above: All Children With Pervasive Developmental Disorders : Normal Functioning intellectual : 70.2 % (N = number of subjects studied = 64)

2. In a previous article, the same authors, Chakrabarti and Fombonne (2001) , Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children JAMA. 2001, 285: 3093-3099. had already done another study, but with a larger sample (N = 97) and had concluded that:

.
" Of the 97 children, 37 children underwent testing Merrill - Palmer and 56 children, the evidence for Preschool and Primary Scale of the Weschler Intelligence . Four children could not be examined for practical reasons. In total, 24 (25.8%) of the 93 children had some degree of mental retardation. Two children with disintegrative disorder child and Rett syndrome were in the range of moderate mental retardation. However, patterns cognitive functioning varied according to diagnosis (Table 2) and, combining together all levels of mental retardation had significant difference found for the presence or absence of mental retardation among three subtypes of PDD (22 = 40.6, P <. 001), el Trastorno Autista era un grupo que tenía más frecuentes y graves retrasos cognitivos que los grupos del síndrome de Asperger and PDD-NOS. . (2)

Those were the results. 25.8% of children with PDD had intellectual disabilities. This means that the 74, 2% of children with ASD had a functioning normal intelligence. L he results of both studies Chakrabarti and Fombonne , the 2005 and the pre-2001 are very similar and therefore a 70, 2% up 74, 2% , children with ASD have normal intelligence.

By category of PDD , this study again confirm that 100% of subjects with Asperger disorder has a normal functioning intelligence are better in the 2001 study results in the 2005 study for the PDD group - NE ( PPD-NOS) with 92, 4% of subjects with a normal range of intelligence, and show almost the same results both studies for subjects more Autistic Disorder: 30.8% of normal intelligence and 69, 2% associated with intellectual disability.

Table 2. Intellectual Functioning by Diagnostic Subgroup (2)
Intellectual Functioning by Diagnostic Sub

4. At all can be considered laymen those responsible for the Guide. I wonder what is interest in excel in a TEA Guide to intellectual disability associated with one of the subgroups, the subgroup Autistic Disorder, which is the subgroup with the highest percentage of disability associated intellectual?.

Why, despite the request for rectification correction has been so sparse, to the extent that it is misleading? Why do not you want to put in the Guide that the vast majority of children with ASD have normal intelligence?

5. Clearly, those responsible for the victims of the topic guide who say that must be eradicated. The social topic says most children with intellectual disabilities associated with ASD have. There are other examples in the Guide where it reappears again and again that topic, for example, a book recommended to families of children with ASD, it becomes to say openly that a majority of children with TEA has intellectual disabilities (mental retardation):

. " About , only one in four children have normal intelligence . The evolution of the intellectual capacity of children with ASD is benefited by early detection and early treatment ." *

Read this, when the ratio is exactly the reverse is disheartening. Only one in four children with ASD have intellectual disabilities. Three in four children with ASD have normal intelligence . Hopefully this article will make you GuíaSalud , To take effect. The Guide has 13 authors, 1 coordinator and 17 external reviewers and presumably many more people in this.

6. Should reflect what appears in paragraph 2 . The measurement of intelligence subjects diagnosed with autism requires testing tailored to the special nature of their verbal and nonverbal development, Article Repairs to strict guidelines on ASD and intellectual disability. , including some reference to that even within the category is controversial Autistic Disorder associated high rates of intellectual disability (67%) when used intelligence tests of character predominantly nonverbal, and included in the bibliography Article The Level Nature and of Autistic Intelligence , Psychological Science , Volume 18 - Number 8, 2007, p. 657-662, authors Michelle Dawson (1), Isabelle Soulières (1, 2), Morton Ann Gernsbacher (3) and Laurent Mottron (1.2).

7. Lastly need to include in their bibliography the extraordinary review the Are Majority of Children With Autism Mentally Retarded ? A Systematic Evaluation of the Data where Meredyth Goldberg Edelson (4) shows the ease with which it has dealt with this issue over the decades, a fact that undoubtedly causes the formation of the topic that everyone, I think, are willing to eradicate. It is a real pleasure to read this review of the data led to establish the topic with revelations completely unexpected and I think a must read for anyone interested in knowing the history of development of their own topic. What has happened to this Guide, with data for the percentage of intellectual disabilities associated with Autistic Disorder TEA and not from research of the authors of the Guide, but references to research others, is a common occurrence and nothing exceptional. But also, and here there is indeed something special is that in such research studies based on others, is a marked tendency to distort the percentage worse intellectual disabilities associated with Autistic Disorder and PDD . And the coordinator of thirteen and seventeen authors external reviewers Clinical Practice Guideline for the management of patients with autism spectrum disorder fall into the same vice of many other authors, defect indicated by Meredyth Goldberg Edelson : increasing arbitrarily intellectual disability rate associated with some or TGD subgroups (p, example: Autistic Disorder). This review of Meredyth Goldberg Edelson kindly provided me Sr. Daniel Comín , creator with his wife Isis forum, http://isis.zm.nu/forum.php?c=19 , through Ms . Anabel Cornago, who edits the blog http://elsonidodelahierbaelcrecer.blogspot.com/ .

8. I have seen with pleasure in the guide how they keep away from other myths, mentioning explicitly that they are myths. Including the myth that relationship at issue here. I hope you agree with these objections rigor in a material and high clinical significance. For transcendence Clinical understand that there are practices that will undoubtedly depend on the outcome and not the reverse. Normally we see what practices are those that improve the prognosis and we think that observing the flow of the relationship is enough. However, there is reverse flow in equal measure. That is, if we think in advance that the outcome will be bad in any way, the intensity of the efforts of clinical practice will be affected for the worse. Palliation appears but not the effort and rigor to reverse the situation. Put a single example. If one considers that children with PDD not look into my eyes and believe that this is an associated symptom, that fact becomes a sign for the diagnosis and we believe that there runs the function of that particular . thus leave the subtleties worry neurological control ocular motility and thus practices that exist rehabilitation purpose. If you think a child does not learn because he is mentally retarded is the perfect excuse to blame the child from his lack of learning. Will reduce the efforts of all.

Related Entries:

Repairs to strict guidelines on ASD and intellectual disability. I

Articles cited:

* A child with autism in the family. Roadmap for families who have been diagnosed with autism for your son or daughter. Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs. Universidad de Salamanca 2007. Available at: http://sid.usal.es/idocs/F8/FDO20581/familia_autismo.pdf . p. 14.

1. (17) View http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/abstract/162/6/1133 : Am J Psychiatry 162:1133-1141, June 2005 © 2005 American Psychiatric Association ; Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children : Confirmation of High Prevalence Suniti Chakrabarti , M.D., F.R.C.P.C.H., M.R.C.P., and Eric Fombonne , M.D., F.R.C.Psych.

2. Ver http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/285/24/3093 :
Vol . 285 No. 24, June 27, 2001; Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children
Suniti Chakrabarti , MD , MRCP ; Eric Fombonne , MD , FRCPsych
JAMA. 2001;285:3093-3099.

3. http://www.guiasalud.es/egpc/autismo/resumida/apartado01/introduccion.html

4. Magnífica revisión http://www.willamette.edu/dept/comm/reprint/edelson/

(1) Pervasive Developmental Disorders Specialized Clinic , Hôpital Rivière-des-Prairies , Montréal, Quebec , Canada, (2) Université of Montréal, Montréal , Quebec, Canada ; and (3) University of Wisconsin - Madison .

0 comments:

Post a Comment