Repairs to strict guidelines on ASD and disability intelectual.I .
test
Examples of Raven's Progressive Matrices.
1. Introduction
Of the many myths of autism is not a minor one, considering that all or most of children diagnosed with autism have been associated with an intellectual disability or cognitive impairment, understood these two terms as mental retardation, the latter expression into disuse. I hope to contribute to this article to eradicate this falsehood. In all this confusion is not a stranger to the unification of the various developmental disorders (autistic disorder, pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified, Asperger's disorder and childhood disintegrative disorder) under the single label ASD, autism spectrum disorder, unification course seriously affects the intellectual production prior clouding the outlook for the understanding of these phenomena on the pretext that such simplification is progress, when the opposite is true. I personally think that this simplification will better accommodate the intensification of child psychiatric diagnoses, articulated through new marketing word of psychiatric disorders: comorbidity ; and that basically that's what drives the conceptual reductionism.
2. It is true that 70% of children with ASD have intellectual disabilities.
serious errors continue to appear in the Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Patients with Autism Spectrum Disorders in Primary Care. We read with astonishment the data on intellectual disability / cognitive people with ASD (autism spectrum disorders) that appear in the above Guide:
"In regard to the effect of cognitive ability, intellectual disability among people with ASD is 70% (30% with mild cognitive impairment and 40% with severe to profound cognitive disabilities), while 30% of subjects show an Intelligence Quotient (IQ) normal or even higher
16.. "
16. Chakrabarti S, Fombonne E. Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children: Confirmation of High Prevalence. Am J Psychiatry 2005 (162): 1133-1141. (**)
The same text, the extended version of the guide (there are two versions, small and expanded!?):
"In regard to the effect of cognitive ability, according to data
some authors , intellectual disability among people with ASD is 70% (30% with cognitive disabilities moderate and 40% with severe to profound cognitive disabilities), while 30% of subjects show an Intelligence Quotient (IQ) normal or even higher
17.. "
17. Chakrabarti S, Fombonne E. Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children: Confirmation of High Prevalence. Am J Psychiatry 2005, 162:1133-1141.
When reviewing the literature of the Guide, the numbers 16 and 17, the short version and extended, respectively, refer to the same article, which in no way says what the authors of the Guide so blithely say that 70% of children with ASD have intellectual disabilities or cognitive.
Without going into now, if IQ tests are applied in research equally well suited to the three subgroups of children examined, children classified by the type of disorder, 1) Autistic Disorder, 2) Pervasive Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified and 3) Asperger disorder, and Limiting ourselves strictly to what we say the authors of the article, Lords. Chakrabarti and Fombonne, in any as can be inferred from his words that the disability of people with ASD (autism spectrum disorders) is 70%, of which 30% correspond to a moderate cognitive impairment and 40% of a disability would be of serious cognitive to profound.
We summarized in the table below (*) investigations Chakrabarti and Fombonne with almost all subgroups of disorders that, taken together, constitute what has been called autistic spectrum disorder, ASD.
to Based on 57 Subjects (21 with autistic disorder, 25 with Pervasive Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified, 11 with Asperger's disorder). Intellectual Functioning WAS Measured IQ with the full measure of the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (11) (N = 29), the quotient derived from the Merrill-Palmer Scale of Mental Tests (12) (N = 22), or the Griffiths Mental Development Scales (Test Agency, Oxford, UK) (N = 6). N is the number of subjects. Intellectual Normal Functioning. Male gender. Click to enlarge. (*)
If you look closely at Table 3, we see that 100% of subjects with Asperger's Disorder and 88% with Pervasive Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified have a normal functional intelligence. That is, in these two subgroups of disorders, the subjects examined have a normal functional intelligence in percentages ranging from 88 to 100%. In other words, the opposite of what it tells us the Clinical Practice Guide referred to above.
Only in the subgroup of autistic disorder, reduces the percentage of normal functional intelligence to 33.3%. Therefore, the authors of the article, 66.7% of patients with Autistic Disorder have a functional intelligence below what is considered normal, the scales of scales of the tests used to determine what the intelligence of all those children. The tests used were: Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence, Merrill-Palmer Scale Mental Tests and Griffiths Mental Development Scales.
course, anyone can understand that can not be the worst performance of one of the three subgroups, in this case the results of the subgroup of autistic disorder, and apply to the whole child, because as we have seen, the other two subgroups of children reach a very high percentage functional intelligence normal (88 to 100% of the subjects examined). We fail to understand what has led to claims the authors of the Guide that among children with autism spectrum disorders are 70% who have intellectual or cognitive disability.
continue reading the article by Chakrabarti and Fombonne, "Significant differences arise between the three groups. The rate of mental retardation in the autistic disorder group is 66.7% compared with 12.0% in the group with pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified, and 0.0% in the Asperger disorder group. In the group with pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified, three subjects with intellectual retardation located in the range of mild mental retardation. In the autistic disorder group six subjects (28.6%) had mild mental retardation and eight subjects (38.1%) had moderate mental retardation to severe.. See page 1138 Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children: Confirmation of High Prevalence.
severity levels associated with IQ (IQ; English IQ) in the previous study are conventional: mild 50-69, moderate 35-49, severe 20-34, and deep, less than 20.
In no way can be said that 70% of children with any autistic spectrum disorder, mental retardation or intellectual disability or cognitive. Childhood disintegrative disorder, another disorder that should be considered in what is called autism spectrum disorders, is not represented in the study on intellectual capacity of the article, but in no way this absence affects what we're saying, because in the overall sample of subjects there is only one child.
So, the Guide should rectify these statements do not conform to the truth and can damage the overall perception of the users of this clinical practice guideline on ASD. However, not only are false data and commented, but you have to call into question the data of the high rate of intellectual disability in the group of children with Autistic Disorder.
2. The measurement of intelligence of subjects with a diagnosis of autism requires
tests adjusted to the special nature of their verbal and nonverbal development.
The second objection on the relationship between autism and intellectual disability or cognitive, is addressed, rather than the authors of the Guide, the paper's conclusions Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children: Confirmation of High Prevalence . Am J Psychiatry 2005 (162): 1133-1141. On the high rate of intellectual disability attributed to the subgroup of children diagnosed with Autistic Disorder, that Messrs.. Chakrabarti and Fombonne rise to 66.7%.
The way to measure the intelligence of children with Autistic Disorder is a controversial issue and there are others who believe that are better suited for this purpose the use of different tests. The following table shows the summary of an investigation that was just to compare the use of two very different types of intelligence test. Markedly from each other marking verbal and non verbal. Just one of the test was controlled Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (WISC) test to be implemented by Chakrabarti and Fombonne the subgroup of children with Autistic Disorder was crucial to these authors consider that 66.7% of them had intellectual disabilities. Intelligence
autistic
Fig. 2. Performance of the (a) autistic and nonautistic Children and (b) autistic adults and nonautistic on the Wechsler scales and Raven's Progressive Matrices. Error bars represents 2 SEMs. WAIS-III = Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Third Edition, WISC-III = Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition.
In the research article The Level and Nature of Autistic Intelligence, Psychological Science, Volume 18-Number 8, 2007, p. 657-662, authors Michelle Dawson (1), Isabelle Soulières (1, 2), Morton Ann Gernsbacher (3) and Laurent Mottron (1.2), found that the Wechsler test results, both in the version for children (WISC) and adults (WAIS), have a strong verbal and as we know, language development in children and adults with Autistic Disorder, is a company not without difficulties. Thus one would expect worse results in the Wechsler test, which test the Raven Progressive Matrices, where language plays a much less important to pass the test.
Looking to Figure 2 , children diagnosed with autism do worse than children without autism in the control group in both the WISC test, like that of Raven . But the differences are much smaller in the Raven, which WISC test. The greatest difference was found in tests intensely verbal nature.
If we now look at Figure 2 b, adults diagnosed with autism perform worse than adults without autism control group only in the test WAIS, while the autistic group gets better results to the control group without autism , in testing Raven. We also note that adults diagnosed with autism reduce the difference in results with the control group on tests of Weschler, with less difference between the two groups on the WAIS test, adult, in the WISC of children. This last fact may be attributable to the further development of language in adults diagnosed with autism.
3. SUMMARY
(For more, see the original article by Michelle Dawson et al.; http://psych.wisc.edu/lang/pdf/Dawson_AutisticIntelligence_PS_2007.pdf )
is assumed that the autistic characterized by cognitive impairment, and cognitive skills are often interpreted as products of low levels of high-level deficits, not as direct manifestations of intelligence. Recent attempts to identify the neuroanatomical and neurophysiological signs of autism have been positioned on this universal but unproven assumption. We proceeded, therefore, to evaluate a broad sample of 38 autistic children in the "test of fluid intelligence, Raven's Progressive Matrices. Their results were, on average, 30 percentage points, and in some cases more than 70 percentage points above their scores on the Weschler intelligence scales. The results of typically developing children showed no such discrepancy, and a similar contrast was observed in a sample of adults with autism compared with a sample of adults with autism. We conclude that the intelligence has been underestimated in autistics. (Michelle Dawson)
Autistics Are Presumed to Be Characterized by cognitive impairment, and their cognitive strengths (e.g., in Block Design performance) are frequently interpreted as low-level by-products of high-level deficits, not as direct manifestations of intelligence. Recent attempts to identify the neuroanatomical and neurofunctional signature of autism have been positioned on this universal, but untested, assumption. We therefore assessed a broad sample of 38 autistic children on the preeminent test of fluid intelligence, Raven’s Progressive Matrices. Their scores were, on average, 30 percentile points, and in some cases more than 70 percentile points, higher than their scores on the Wechsler scales of intelligence. Typically developing control children showed no such discrepancy, and a similar contrast was observed when a sample of autistic adults was compared with a sample of non autistic adults. We conclude that intelligence has been underestimated in autistics. (Michelle Dawson)
4. Información adicional sobre el Test de Raven y Weschler:
4.1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven
4.2. http://marpsi.blogspot.com/2008/06/raven.html <---(simulador test Raven on-line)
(*) Table adapted from Chakrabarti S, Fombonne E. Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Preschool Children: Confirmation of High Prevalence. Am J Psychiatry 2005 (162): Page 1138.
(**) See original article Chakrabarti and Fombonne in: http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/reprint/162/6/1133 .
(1) Pervasive Developmental Disorders Specialized Clinic, Hôpital Rivière-des-Prairies, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, (2) Université de Montréal, Montréal, Quebec, Canada, and (3) University of Wisconsin-Madison.
can see the Guide to Autism: http://www.guiasalud.es/egpc/autismo/resumida/apartado01/introduccion.html
0 comments:
Post a Comment